“Mmphh?”
“Ugh this’ll probably be easier if you can talk,” Jake said as he pulled off the tape over his nose and went to undo the tape around Joe’s mouth. Suddenly, the doorbell rang, making Joe and I panic, not sure who else was here, while Xavier looked over to Jake confused.
“Oh shit, I forgot about him. Hold that thought, hey, do you mind getting that?” Jake told Xavier. He got up and headed out towards the door, opening it. Meanwhile, Jake got up and gave me a kiss, and started to head over to the basement door. I moaned out to him, not wanting to be left alone with whoever was coming in.
“Ssshhh it’s okay, he won’t touch you…and if he does, there’ll be hell to pay,” he said, winking at me. I struggled against the tape binding me, but then heard Xavier yell out.
“What the—” he started to say, before being interrupted. We heard struggling and scuffling, with Joe grunting out, probably worried about his friend. I heard someone approaching the living room, and soon Xavier was pushed in, falling onto the ground next to Joe, with his hands zip-tied behind his back and a huge red ball gag forcing his mouth wide open.
Out from behind him stood someone who looked almost exactly like Jake, or at least a younger version of him. This must’ve been Jack, his younger brother. Joe and Xavier’s old childhood friend. The one that Joe hazed all those years ago. He looked down at Joe and Xavier with a cold expression, intimidating them and making them look away from his gaze. It wasn’t hatred, but there was definitely bitterness and anger behind his eyes. He bent down and pulled Xavier’s bare feet together, zip-tying them and forcing him on his knees like Joe. As he was checking Xavier’s bonds, he looked over at me and was startled.
Jack
“Jesus!! Fuck, dude, you scared me! Who the fuck are you?”
I moaned out, trying to say my name, but the tape and sock prevented any intelligible sound from escaping. But it soon clicked for him, and he looked back with a softer and kinder expression.
“Wait you’re Bobby! Yeah Jake was telling me about you! Jack said, looking at me with a grin, “I can see why he’s so infatuated with you. Well bro, welcome to the family! No diss to Sarah, but I think you’re better for him. I mean the way he talked about you after one day…well I never heard him talk about Sarah like that.”
I blushed at hearing Jack talk about his brother who had been talking nonstop about me. Had I not been tied up for the whole day, I would’ve been doing the same with my friends. Joe and Xavier struggled and grunted, probably confused as to what Jack was talking about. I was a bit embarrassed that Jack was being so open about it, but I knew that’s what Jake wanted to talk about when he brought us all upstairs. Not that I was in any position to do anything about it anyways. Jack looked over at the two but ignored them and kept talking at me.
“Plus, it helps that you’re kinky as fuck like him,” he said, winking back at me, “Anyways, don’t worry, we’ll take better care of you than this asshole,” he said, gesturing at Joe. He still looked confused, struggling to put together the hints that Jack kept dropping about his brother and me. He then groaned back, trying to plead with Jack for mercy, while Xavier just sat there, sniffling and looking down. Jack grabbed the bag lying at his feet and pulled out two pairs of nipple clamps, connected by chains. Joe and Xavier struggled and cried out, shaking their heads and trying to beg, but Jake didn’t care.
“Shut up! You guys look way too comfy,” he said as he sat in front of Joe, looking back at me, “Haha I hope your nipples aren’t sensitive because these belong to Jake.”
I moaned out and squirmed on the couch, making Jack laugh. He turned back at Joe and put the clamps before Joe could even react. After a few seconds, Joe was crying out and struggling against the tape binding him, looking up at Jack with pleading eyes. But Jack ignored him, giving them a few tugs and making Joe cry out. He then moved over to Xavier, who was nearly in tears again. Jack noticed and sighed, sitting down next him and lifting Xavier’s head up comfort his old friend.
“Hey,” he said softly, “you know why I’m doing this, right? For what you and Joe put me through.”
Xavier moaned back, tears rolling down his cheek. I then heard the basement door open and looked over to see Jake walk into the living room, who interrupted on Xavier’s behalf.
“Actually Jack, he didn’t know. He just found out tonight,” Jake said as he sat down next to me, looking over at Xavier, who nodded back, “Joe fucked him over, making you think that they both were in on it, isn’t that right?” he said to Joe, who grudgingly nodded back. Jack’s eyes widened, and he immediately went to free Xavier with his pocketknife.
“Shit! Xavier, I’m so sorry! I thought you knew all this time, and I was so mad! Honestly I was more pissed off at Joe, but I was more hurt thinking that you had a role to play,” he said as he started to cut at the zip-tie binding his hands, but Jake stopped him.
“Not to tell you what to do, but I think you’ll find that he actually enjoys being restrained,” Jake said, pointing to Xavier’s bulge. He moaned out, struggling against the zip-tie, embarrassed by Jake telling Jack how turned on he was. Jack looked over and smiled at his friend.
“Haha you little freak,” he laughed, making Xavier blush and look away, “Hey it’s okay, I’m just kidding…to be honest, I kinda suspected it.”
Xavier moaned back in confusion, making Jack laugh a bit.
“I mean I’ve seen your box of tape and rope under your bed…and I’ve seen you sniffing my socks a few times…and I saw the porn you watch. Haha it turns out you watch the same stuff as Jake,” Jack said, with Jake jokingly kicking his brother in the back. Xavier looked down again, ashamed, but Jack put his arm over his shoulders.
“Hey…it’s okay. I never said anything because I didn’t want you to feel ashamed. Not that you should’ve, but I figured you must’ve felt that way since you were always hiding everything,” he said, making Xavier smile, or at least attempt to with the huge gag in his mouth. Jack smiled back and ruffled his hair.
“I can leave you like this if you want…” Jack asked, with Xavier nodding in excitement. Jack helped him back to the ottoman and undid the zip-ties. He pulled Xavier’s hands in front and retied them, making Xavier more comfortable.
“I’m really sorry, Xavier. It was stupid, I should’ve just talked to you and gotten your side of things. I hope you can forgive me…and maybe when you’re not so tied up, we can hang out,” he said as he re-tied his friend’s feet more comfortably, with Xavier grunting back in excitement. Jack smiled and lightly slapped Xavier’s gagged face, making him giggle, and then started to lightly tickle his bare feet. Xavier giggled and moaned out, shaking his head and squirming on the ottoman, but Jack was only encouraged to keep going. He wasn’t as intense as Joe and the twins, so Xavier probably had sensitive feet. Jake then started to lightly pull at his friend’s nipples.
“MMPHH!” Xavier cried out, as Jack smiled deviously down at him.
“You sure you don’t want to try those clamps? I think your nipples would be perfect for them,” he said as he kept pulling and pinching. Xavier shook his head as he moaned and struggled, and he gave Xavier a break. He ruffled his hair and came back to the couch, sitting next to his brother with Joe in front of him. He grabbed the long chain that connected to the nipple clamps, tugging on them and making Joe groan and cry out, trying to move closer so it didn’t hurt as much. But Jake held his size 12 shoe against Joe’s chest to keep him in place, tugging harder and harder.
“Don’t worry, Joe, I didn’t forget about you. You know, I thought I’d feel better seeing like this, tied up and gagged with a fucking disgusting jockstrap like I was, but…it just reminds me of the fact that you humiliated me in front of the team. In front of Jake!” Jack yelled at Joe, “You threw 14 years of friendship away! And why?! Because you were jealous?! You were the one wanting to replace Mark, not me! And instead of owning up to your shit, you just texted, saying it was just a joke and that I was being a bitch for quitting!”
It was quiet for a few minutes. Xavier looked over at Joe and Jack, sad to see Jack so hurt, and struggled against his binds, probably just wanting to embrace his friends. Joe was looking down, unable to look at his former friend in the eyes, tearing up from his friend’s angry words and the nipple torture. Meanwhile, Jake had me cuddled in his arms, teasing my nipples and rubbing my bound chest. I moaned a bit, but he shushed me, not wanting me to interrupt his brother. Jack leaned back against the couch, having calmed down a bit but still tugging his nipples every few seconds.
“High school was ruined, Joe. Not only because I quit football, but because I lost my two best friends,” he said, pausing for a bit before leaning towards Joe and making him look up, “I don’t know…maybe I can forgive you. I’d be lying if I said I haven’t missed you, despite what you did. But you still need to be punished. Jake took it into his own hands, but I want to the one doing it to you…”
Joe shook his head at the mention of further punishment, but Jack kept tugging at the nipple clamps as he continued talking.
“Oh, you’ll definitely be punished. Did you know that Mark actually texted me? Before he graduated? Guess he felt guilty because he just sent text after text saying how he learned that you were the one aiming for his spot and how he was so sorry.”
Joe looked up at Jack in surprise, probably not expecting Mark to be the apologizing guy. Jack tugged harder, making Joe cry out.
“I asked him about what he had planned for me, since he couldn’t stop bragging about taking me back to his place. He didn’t want to say at first, but eventually he told me…and I think it’s only fair that you get a taste of what he had planned for me.”
